A student investigates two neutral main-group elements, Element X with ground-state electron configuration 1s22s22p63s23p4 and Element Y with 1s22s22p63s23p64s23d104p4. The student hypothesizes that these elements exhibit similar chemical properties because they possess identical numbers of valence electrons. Which statement correctly evaluates this hypothesis by identifying the valence electron count and the specific occupied orbitals for both elements?
- A) The hypothesis is correct; both elements have 6 valence electrons found in the highest principal energy level (3s23p4 for Element X and 4s24p4 for Element Y).
- B) The hypothesis is incorrect; Element X has 6 valence electrons, whereas Element Y has 16 valence electrons because its filled 3d10 subshell is also considered valence.
- C) The hypothesis is correct; both elements have 4 valence electrons because only the electrons in the outermost p subshells act as valence electrons.
- D) The hypothesis is incorrect; Element X has 4 valence electrons (3p4) and Element Y has 14 valence electrons (3d104p4) because filled s subshells are core electrons.